“This” (in case you can’t see it via the link above) was a glurgy piece of nostalgia porn misogyny masquerading as poetry. My emotions shifted through ennui to rage to disgust (and not just because of the font used) pretty quickly, briefly eased by Hannah’s magnificent rant against it.
But this is me, and it was lunchtime, so: riposte poem time:
Text version:
A Poem To Which I Can Relate
I remember the corned beef of my Childhood,
And the bread that we cut with a knife,
When the Children helped with the housework,
And the men went to work not the wife.
The cheese never needed a fridge,
And the bread was so crusty and hot,
The Children were seldom unhappy,
And the Wife was content with her lot.
I remember the milk from the bottle,
With the yummy cream on the top,
Our dinner came hot from the oven,
And not from a freezer; or shop.
The kids were a lot more contented,
They didn’t need money for kicks,
Just a game with their friends in the road,
And sometimes the Saturday flicks.
…
I remember the slap on my backside,
And the taste of soap if I swore
Anorexia and diets weren’t heard of
And we hadn’t much choice what we wore.
Do you think that bruised our ego?
Or our initiative was destroyed?
We ate what was put on the table
And I think life was better enjoyed.
Author
Unknown
|
A
Poem To Which WE Can Relate
The
silence that cut like a knife
Where
Children were seen and not heard
And
blows clamped down marital strife
The
Wife could not claim her possessions,
Worked
for nothing in kitchen and bed;
The
Children were gifted this vision:
That’s
your future until you are dead.
We remember
the Childhood diseases
That
took all but lucky or strong
Darwinianism
in action
And
no-one to challenge our wrongs.
We
gazed at the chasm dividing
The
have-nots from those haves who strode
Over
huge tracts of land that were paid for
By
theft, tax, and History’s goad.
Those
who were beaten learned nothing
Except
how to govern by fear
Girls
were pressed into corsets and wasted away
You
won’t learn if you don’t try to hear
The
privileged never do question
From
whence comes their food and their board
You
whine incognito as we change the world
With
your death rattle justly ignored.
Fay Roberts
|
The beautiful picture of Ruby Rose in the Westinghouse style was created by the ridiculously talented Eddie Holly.
Feel free to share if you like. A surprising number of people already have, which both weirds me out and gratifies me (yay! imposter syndrome!), and the original Facebook version is here.
UPDATE: Bloody hell - there's a longer version. Turns out the ... bit in the one to which I responded is to indicate where there were more lines, but the perpetrator pinched them out in order to be able to fit the meat of the “poem” on a single side of A4.
I was trying to identify the author of the original, to go with my own angry reply when I came across this. Well written!
ReplyDeleteThanks! Would love to see your angry reply when it's done! :)
DeleteThe most I could find out was that it's apparently called "Nostalgia" (of course it is), but no-one's laying claim to it.
Brilliant reply. This kind of fuckwittery annoys the hell out of me. People froze in their houses as they only had one source of heating. Food being cooked from scratch is great if you have the time or the energy but it is one of the worst kinds of snobbery to think that it all has to be made from scratch because you have days when you just want to bitch-slap your boss and you can't face coming in and cooking for the next two hours.
ReplyDeleteThanks! (SOrry for the delay in replying - got ill, then got buried in emails! :-/)
DeleteIt's the worst kind of glurgey sentamentalism that forgets how very rife that is with ableism, and smugness. And lack of ability to understand the real - but different - struggles that people nowadays have (never mind conveniently editing out memories of early, painful deaths and grim diseases).
I just stumbled on the original rose-misted doggerel in my town facebook feed, and was also infuriated to stop all useful work and write a retort (only found yours afterwards). This was mine:
ReplyDeleteI remember the rickets of my childhood
And the boy who got polio and died
When the kids lived in fear of a caning
And the women? We kept them inside.
There were one or two channels on telly
The only accent they broadcast was ‘posh’
But it’s not like we had time to watch it
As the boss kept us under the cosh.
We didn’t have smartphones or WiFi
We were locked into one job for life
There was slim chance you’d live through your 60s
But at least you could beat up the wife.
It was fine to make jokes about foreigners
The only people who mattered were whites
‘Gay’? It meant ‘happy’, not… y’know
And thank God that they didn’t have rights.
Do you think all this stunted our worldview?
Closed our minds off to novel ideas?
Well, so what? I’ve a triple-locked pension
And my mortgage has been paid for years.
The ‘PC brigade’, the ‘thought police’,
All those snowflakes who may disagree…
They can shut up, because it’s not my fault
The world’s grown too complex for me.
Wow, that's some powerfully sarcastic stuff there (I dearly hope it's sarcastic!).
DeleteI saw that crap corned beef poem just the other day and also had to pen my own response. I live in Ireland so some of my references are geographical.
ReplyDeleteI remember being sick in my childhood
I remember being cut by that knife
My mother worked for a man who became Taoiseach
But had to quit work when she became “wife”
The cheese? It was that crap “Calvita”
The bread, to be fair, was OK
But so many kids were unhappy
It was so often hidden away
There were so many things that were better
But a whole lot more that were worse
I'm not going to spell them out singly
I'm not going to put them in verse
But please don't give me sweet poetry
That simplifies life in the past
That erases the lives of the weak ones
Whose own destinies dice didn't cast
There was abuse by church, state and family
That the soap taste will not wash away
And no, there was no anorexia
But then neither was there any “Gay”
And yes, it bruised many an ego
And many a dream was destroyed
So let's hear your rebuffs and rebuttles
Let's get your come-backs deployed.
Oouff. Powerful stuff. Thanks for sharing!
DeleteHave to ask though, just to be sure: what do you mean by there wasn't any "Gay"?